48355: oskarloko - Wednesday, October 1 2025 - 12:40 AM
It reminds me of someone...
48356: cn - Wednesday, October 1 2025 - 12:54 AM
So you're saying you could make me like doing paperwork?
I'm sold!
48357: random - Wednesday, October 1 2025 - 1:26 AM
Well, Noah's wishes appear to be able to alter reality (assuming the nightmares are considered reality), so he is the "upgraded version" of this ability. Their hair color matches, I wonder if he is her child. We have never learned about his family, anyway. (Unless I missed something).
48358: obscursythia - Wednesday, October 1 2025 - 1:34 AM
Ciel, is that you ?!
48359: Syhkane - Wednesday, October 1 2025 - 2:28 AM
People keep saying mother, but I think Noah is her reincarnation.
48360: BisectedBrioche - Wednesday, October 1 2025 - 2:58 AM
I mean, Noah's mother disowned him for being a magic user. And I suspect his dad would have mentioned the hypocrisy, if nothing else.
Held's timeline seems to be taking place in the distant past, so she's probably a distant ancestor or Noah's a reincarnation or something.
48361: oskarloko - Wednesday, October 1 2025 - 3:28 AM
It can give mental wishes, so a perfect psychiatrist / psychologist.
48362: Tom - Wednesday, October 1 2025 - 3:47 AM
Wishes, you say?
48363: Lurklife - Wednesday, October 1 2025 - 4:05 AM
Is it weird that I think Noah is going to be a byproduct of her abilities? Not like something she created, but more something she became?
48364: Fuz - Wednesday, October 1 2025 - 9:02 AM
So it doesn't grant wishes.
48365: Mallory - Wednesday, October 1 2025 - 3:10 PM
Well I can certainly see why she didn’t live through to Noah’s time.
48366: Zed - Wednesday, October 1 2025 - 3:38 PM
It feels weird to call "making someone fall in love with you" a material realm wish.
48367: Darius Drake - Wednesday, October 1 2025 - 5:12 PM
So you can grant the wishes that a Genie typically can't (nowadays), primarily because they're disturbing and disruptive to free will.
I'm going to SAY that isn't disturbing, while trying to hope you die suddenly long before I am affected by your power. Preferably while running far, FAR away from you.
48368: Ulan - Wednesday, October 1 2025 - 6:38 PM
But does the physical world include the spirit realm?
I'm enjoying all of Held's story.
48369: Whispers of Sorrow - Thursday, October 2 2025 - 12:00 AM
@Lurklife: Not at all. That or something similar seems far more likely than any mundane connection.
48370: noname - Thursday, October 2 2025 - 12:56 AM
This child could cure my depression and sort out the unravelling mess that is my mind...
@Zed
Eh, I disagree. "Make that person fall in love with me" is a material/physical wish, but "Make me fall in love with that person" would be an immaterial/mental wish.
48373: Whispers of Sorrow - Thursday, October 2 2025 - 2:15 AM
@Darius Drake: You may have misread. She's saying she *can't* grant those wishes. Or are you presuming other wish granting powers that happen to horrify you?
It reminds me of someone...
So you're saying you could make me like doing paperwork?
I'm sold!
Well, Noah's wishes appear to be able to alter reality (assuming the nightmares are considered reality), so he is the "upgraded version" of this ability. Their hair color matches, I wonder if he is her child. We have never learned about his family, anyway. (Unless I missed something).
Ciel, is that you ?!
People keep saying mother, but I think Noah is her reincarnation.
I mean, Noah's mother disowned him for being a magic user. And I suspect his dad would have mentioned the hypocrisy, if nothing else.
Held's timeline seems to be taking place in the distant past, so she's probably a distant ancestor or Noah's a reincarnation or something.
It can give mental wishes, so a perfect psychiatrist / psychologist.
Wishes, you say?
Is it weird that I think Noah is going to be a byproduct of her abilities? Not like something she created, but more something she became?
So it doesn't grant wishes.
Well I can certainly see why she didn’t live through to Noah’s time.
It feels weird to call "making someone fall in love with you" a material realm wish.
So you can grant the wishes that a Genie typically can't (nowadays), primarily because they're disturbing and disruptive to free will.
I'm going to SAY that isn't disturbing, while trying to hope you die suddenly long before I am affected by your power. Preferably while running far, FAR away from you.
But does the physical world include the spirit realm?
I'm enjoying all of Held's story.
@Lurklife: Not at all. That or something similar seems far more likely than any mundane connection.
This child could cure my depression and sort out the unravelling mess that is my mind...
@Zed
Eh, I disagree. "Make that person fall in love with me" is a material/physical wish, but "Make me fall in love with that person" would be an immaterial/mental wish.
@Darius Drake: You may have misread. She's saying she *can't* grant those wishes. Or are you presuming other wish granting powers that happen to horrify you?